I had the opportunity to read/listen and review the Palaces of the Crows by Ray Nayler - produced by Macmillan Audio.
This was my first book by Ray Nayler, and it was INTENSE. I am not entirely sure it is representative of his other works, but I do intend to check out more from him.
This book is really quite unique and I noted several folks doing reviews didn't finish it. Crows, and Crow friends are kind of a hot commodity in the Book tok world So perhaps readers were expecting one thing, and got something different. I personally initially ignored this one because I am wholly exhausted from the onslaught of World War Two historic fiction. In the current climate, it makes me feel some kind of way. that said, I'm glad that I took this one on, because it fed a piece of my soul.
For me, this was a book that grew on me. The initial chapters- which introduced us to the main characters were admittedly not the most engaging/easy to follow, AND, they introduced readers to a bit of a bleak landscape and situation, which at times overwhelmed me with a sense of doom, and dread. As much as I didn't enjoy that, I have to hand it to Nayler. I was immersed. I listened to this as part of my daily commute and at the beginning found that I often walked into my house after my commute home with a severe sense of dread. I finally fully comprehended that my entire sense of dread was Audiobook induced, and I started to enjoy Nayler's work more.
The basic premise - without any spoilers- is 4 young people find themselves sandwiched between the German troops, and the Red Army troops in a forest during WWII. They didn't know each other "before" and their alliance seems to be one of the most unlikely ever. These children band together and are helped by a variety flora, fauna, and some humans. But they are especially helped by a band of highly intelligent crows that one of them had befriended over the years. This survival story unfolds into a panorama of survival through mutual aid, loyalty, storytelling and a unique human/animal relationship.
I stuck with this book, despite also not really vibing with the first part because I was curious about why Nayler had taken on this topic and decided to tell this story. I feel that it's worth it for the "third act" if you will which shows the eventual resolution of the desperate situation the characters began in and gave me a unique view on power, people in power, and the motivations of those who seek, obtain and maintain power. The choices made by the young persons- if they can be called choices- were heart wrenching. If someone had told me I'd be sobbing at any time reading a Ray Nayler novel, I would not have believed it, but I actually did shed a tear or two. The third portion of the novel really hits home.
This was narrated by Eunice Wong, who showcased her talent to take on this project and deliver a reading that was clear, but also reflected many difficult emotions throughout the novel.
This is a unique book, one that transported me to a very uncomfortable spot, but also left me with many small gifts and realizations. I recommend it for readers particularly interested in difficult choices, mutual aid, and of course, human/animal relationships.
First Published : 5/19/26
Pages: 384
Available as an Audio Book : yes ~ 8 hours
Trigger Warnings: War, death, violence, extreme cold, parental loss, loss of identity (this is not a full list, read responsibly)