Book Review : The First Thousand Trees by Premee Mohamed 4/5 stars

 I'm starting to be a big fan of Premee Mohamed. It's not often that I feel like there's a book written specifically "for ME"  but this entire trilogy seems like it might be. 

   I expected this novel to follow Reid as she returned to her campus, but instead we follow Henryk on his journey to  his Uncle's more Northern community. 

Short No Spoiler ( I hope!) synopsis:

Feeling bereft after Reid's departure, Henryk sets out on a wild adventure, traveling with a makeshift map to find his Uncle. With more luck than skill, he's able to find the community. Henryk is taken in conditionally and really does give it his all to fit in and be visibly productive in a vastly different community than the one he left. He struggles much in the same way he struggled at home, making some poor decisions, and being, in general, not very welcome. Much like his past, as series of disasters follows him, and while none are notable his "fault" dystopian communities seem to have no time for accidental blunders.  After a particularly spectacular error Henryk somewhat redeems himself and makes a choice to move on. 

For me, I wanted Henryk to desperately have sort of a hero's arc of redemption, but that does not occur, and to be honest, this seems so realistic as so many of us work very hard at being in community with others, and despite our efforts we aren't always successful. 

In the end, the message I took away again was that people often survive better together, and no one really wins unless everyone can share in the winning.  I love this message as it's one I believe in whole heartedly. 

The writing again is precise and story construction is on point. These novellas are great for book club as there's so much to discuss- themes of belonging, community, class systems, the environment, poverty and wealth, community building and more! 

The First Thousand Trees comes out September 30th!  I am grateful to ECW press for the opportunity to read the novella as an Advanced copy! 

STATS

First Published : September 2025

Pages: 136

Available as an Audio Book : not currently, but maybe soon? 

Trigger Warnings: Climate crisis, Death of child, death of parent, blood, medical situation, violence, weaponry,   (not a complete list- be responsible!)

Book Review: We Speak Through the Mountain by Premee Mohamed 5/5 Stars

 Sometimes the middle book in a trilogy is considered the weak one.  If this is the weak one, I cannot wait to read book three!!!! 

 We Speak Through The Mountain picks up right where The Annual Migration of Clouds leaves off.  I highly recommend just reading the two as one novel, because they are novellas, and book two is where this really gains steam. 

(Take a moment to look at this cover!) 

No Spoilers- because spoilers are just wrong. Readers will continue a journey with our main character Reid as she reaches the fabled Howse University. This climate dystopia continues to help readers imagine life after climate collapse; instead of being on the outside looking in, the reader is now taken into the protected domes which had preserved life to pre-collapse times.  We learn some answers to many of the questions raised in the first book.  Reid settles in to university life, although she's uneasy about many things that others seem to accept without question. She's resolute in pursuing her goal to help those outside the glittering protective dome despite strong disapproval from leaders and her peers. When bad news come from home, Reid embarks on a new journey that promises to be full of risky adventure.  (which I am super excited to follow in the next novella!) 

   At the crux of the novella series is an age old conflict between responsibility to self, family and the community overall. This conflict is set in a futuristic, but realistic world which is well imagined and easily understood.  Mohamed's writing remains clear, compelling and cinematic. As I realized I was at "the end" I felt a bit torn away from the setting that I had become immersed in, and I wondered why this hasn't been optioned for film! 

  I really liked this novella, and I think it would be a fantastic one for young adult students to read and discuss. 

I have book three tee'd up thanks to Net Galley  and ECW Press  and I can't wait to come back and (without spoilers...) tell you how it concludes. 

STATS

First Published : June 2024

Pages: 152

Available as an Audio Book : YES

Trigger Warnings: violence, blood, death, grief, medical situations,  (not a complete list- be responsible!)

Book Review Black Water, by David Robertson 3.5/5 Stars

   Continuing with my 2025 theme of Water- I read Black Water- Family, legacy and Blood memory  by David A Robertson.  

This was not a light recollection of the childhood of a Cree man in Canada. It was an award winner and best seller but I did find it a bit difficult to get through, likely a me problem, more than an author problem. 

  I was fascinated by the story to start with. David is the son of a Cree father and a white mother. For unknown reasons, the Cree side of his heritage was never discussed, so much so that when questioned about his ethnicity- he entirely denied being "indian"  and had no real feeling that he was Indigenous, despite having apparently a typical Cree appearance which was noticed (and commented one) by folks around him.  

       Robertson tells essentially a dual memoir, one of his father, a man who grew up on a reservation, and became a pastor and academic leader in Indigenous education, and one of himself, a man who grew up with a largely absent father  and no awareness of his own roots. 

   Robertson does not flinch away from the many truths about his life, and the lives of Indigenous people in Canada. He's able to pull in so much material and relate it to his life, but also the outer world around us. While he mourns not growing up more aware of his Cree heritage, he understands that growing up with more knowledge doesn't mean that his life would have been "easier"  or "better", just different.  Although in the writing, I can see that he does clearly believe that not knowing did cause some unspoken trauma, which may have lead to some mental health concerns. 

   Robertson is given a new chance to really get to know his Dad, when he re-enters their lives more fully, and he takes full advantage of this, as he and his Dad visit Dad's old home, and David records hours of memories, from not only his Dad but other relatives and friends, and becomes familiar with the people and the land his Dad grew up on - David anchors himself a bit to the land, and it's fascinating to read as things come full circle, David has his own family and chooses a very different path for his children who are growing up fully aware of their heritage. 

    I wasn't swept away by this book. I don't believe that was the point of the book, I feel the author wanted to raise awareness and generate discussion. I definitely might put this one forward as a Book Club book!   For me - I felt like the author didn't entirely commit and sort of danced around a few topics - which I felt perhaps he hadn't completely resolved for himself, but of course, he's still living, and aren't we all experiencing, adjusting and changing our minds as we continue on our life journey.  At the same time that I wasn't swept away,  I recognized it as an important piece of writing, that offers thoughts on belonging, identity, generational trauma, family, racism, internalized racism, and more.  I also recognized that the work done on this book, the research etc, likely informed Robertson's The Theory of Crows published 2 years later. 

I did read this via Audiobook  and it is narrator by the author. I will say the author has a bit of a reedy quality to his voice, and POSSIBLY I might have enjoyed this more with different voice, but when a book is narrated by the author, you know you're getting the whole she-bang so to speak, so, maybe if I were doing it again, I'd read the book in print. 

STATS

First Published 2020

Pages: 288

Available as an Audio Book : YES

Trigger Warnings:  Racism, Mental health discussion, 

(this is not a full list, read responsibly)

Book Review: Kiss of the Fur Queen by Tomson Highway 5/5 stars

 Kiss of the Fur Queen by Tomson Highway is a masterpiece. I discovered it mostly because I was a little disappointed in another book and wanted to read more Cree literature.  First published in 1998 in Canada, it is the author's only novel. Although it is now several decades old, it reads as if it were a freshly published novel and I am surprised that more people are not reading it, given the recent discoveries and discussion regarding Residential schools in both Canada and the United States.  With our new awareness of these "schools" I think this is an important read, especially as it was written, back when I couldn't have told you about the Residential Schools in any serious way and, it gives a nod to the missing/murdered indigenous woman that has been only recently before the public eye. 

     In short, the Kiss of the Fur Queen follows the story of two Cree boys in the 1950's in Canada. They are removed from their homes and sent to a Catholic residential school. There, the boys are subjected to multiple types of abuse, but continue to grow and learn, traveling to a modern city for high school and beyond. The boys straddle traditional Cree culture and modern Canadian culture with great difficulty, eventually finding success in the arts. Throughout the novel, they periodically interact with the enigmatic Fur Queen - who seems to represent the trickster, Wisakedjak. She shows up often at times of decisions and high emotions, reminding the two main characters of the Indigenous culture and values.  The magical realism of the book- really grabbed me, as it just elevated this book from being a story of two Indigenous men removed from their culture.

   The themes and ideas explored throughout the book are specific to Indigenous culture but also broad enough to encompass the humanity as a whole. Highway 's work addresses the complexities of the world, as see through the eyes of children, relationships between siblings, the experience of shared trauma, culture, if one can ever really "return home" after being away and the many forms of grief individuals can experience through life. The writing is impeccable, and although the subject matter was difficult, I found myself fully focused on the trajectory of these two men, their choices and eventually the conclusion. For me, this MAY be one of my most important reads of 2025. I noted some mixed reviews of a review site, and did note that many people couldn't explain why they didn't like the book- they just acknowledged it was an important book but it "wasn't for them" so I suspect, it may have made them extremely uncomfortable with the truth exposed in a brutal but engaging way. Some did cite the blending of the real with the unreal, but I just didn't see that the blending was that fantastical or weird, I think it just covered A LOT of uncomfortable topics without euphemisms or other ways to allow readers to pretend they didn't just read *that*.  

 I listened to this book via Audio. The Narrator is Patricia Cano, who did an amazing job bringing a lyrical quality to the work, and definitely added to my enjoyment- especially given some of the more difficult and long place and people names. Definitely recommend audio. 

STATS:

First Published: 1998

Pages: 320

Available as an Audiobook: YES

Trigger warnings: Child loss,  Parent loss, alcohol use, depression , Child abuse, SA, generational trauma.

As always this is not a complete list, please read responsible.