Wow! This is a holiday Rom-com that packs a punch and addresses many serious topics while still injecting humor. Quite a balancing act, and one that Jean Meltzer does extremely well!
Many Thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin audio for the audiobook, read by Dara Rosenberg.
I listened to the audiobook with a friend as a buddy read and we both LOVED this! I chose it because I thought it might be a good one to recommend when people are looking for a romance that is from a different culture. Now, this is set in contemporary Manhattan for the most part and the main characters are mainstream modern Jewish people, but many readers aren't very familiar with Jewish culture and Meltzer does a great job introducing some concepts and traditions that are different and somewhat unique while spinning a ridiculously funny and at the same time heartbreaking second chance romance. I definitely learned so many things about Jewish culture and family!
Without spoilers- Evelyn is a dedicated, driven TV executive, while David is a laid back physician. They married, having a passionate love and shared values between them, but after a tragic event, they drift apart with David settling down on a hobby farm in Pennsylvania. Evelyn is producing a massive holiday extravaganza, when she's suddenly confronted by David who is doing a stint as the production studio doctor. Things get awkward! Evelyn is visited by multiple ghosts of Hanukkah as she revisits past moments, she gains perspective on past events, while David is faced with his continued feelings for Evelyn. Can a Hanukkah miracle happen for this unlikely couple? Well, of course you'll want to read to find out.
I enjoyed the audiobook. Dara Rosenburg did a great job conveying personality through her narration, and I definitely felt Evelyn's tension and David's more mellow demeanor through the narration!
Please note the trigger warnings prior to embarking on this journey. The cartoon cover makes it seem like a campy rom- com, but within the pages, Meltzer also seamlessly addresses pregnancy loss, grief, loss of parent, divorce, and more. So, it's important to decide if this is a novel for you, or one you'd give as a gift. Both of us buddy readers did ugly cry hard through some parts of the book. That said, we also could not stop laughing at some of the other parts!
First Published : 10/2025
Pages: 368
Available as an Audio Book :YES
Trigger Warnings: medical situations, chronic illness, pregnancy loss, child loss, parental death, divorce, irrational main star, chickens and Llamas.
Not a full TW list, please read responsibly.